Key takeaways
NSW paused its new underquoting reforms on 16 November, just hours before they were due to start on 17 November.
Mandatory price guides, the ban on advertising below rejected offers and penalties of up to $110,000 are all on hold, possibly for up to 12 months.
Existing underquoting laws still apply, so agents can't treat the pause as a green light.
The government admitted the laws were written for a rising market and didn't fit the one we're in now.
For investors, the lesson is to do your own homework on value, because a price guide was never a valuation.
After months of preparation, detailed guidance from NSW Fair Trading and a formal start date, the NSW Government pulled the handbrake on its underquoting reforms with less than a day to go.
Many real estate agents had spent around a month rewriting their processes and advertising templates to comply, only to be told on Sunday evening that none of it would be needed just yet.
What makes this episode worth paying attention to isn't the politics, although there's plenty of that. It's what the backflip tells us about how property laws get written, and how quickly the assumptions behind them can be overtaken by a turn in the market cycle.

How it unfolded
The timeline is almost comical in hindsight.
On 29 October, NSW Fair Trading published its detailed implementation guidance for the industry.
On 1 November, the government formally confirmed the reforms would commence on 17 November.
Then on Monday 16 November, Premier Chris Minns stepped in, and by that evening the start date had been shelved.
The legislation itself had passed Parliament back in June, so this wasn't a half-baked proposal that fell over in consultation - it was law that was ready to go live.
Reports suggest the pause could last up to 12 months, although that timeframe hasn't been officially locked in, and it's still unclear whether the reforms will come back in their current form or be reworked.
What was put on hold
Three big changes were meant to start this week.
The first was mandatory price disclosure, requiring agents to advertise a price or price range, which would have effectively ended "price on application" and "contact agent" listings in NSW.
The second was a new, explicit restriction on advertising a property below a written offer the vendor had rejected, or below the highest bid at a passed-in auction.
The third was a big lift in penalties, with the maximum fine for underquoting jumping from $22,000 to $110,000 or three times the agent's commission, whichever was higher.
The reforms also required price estimates to be based on the three most comparable recent sales, and for advertising to be updated within one business day of an estimate changing.
All of that is now in limbo.
Why the government caved
Premier Minns was unusually candid about the reasoning. He said agents in his own electorate had told him the rules could stop sellers and agents from reducing an advertised price when a property simply wasn't attracting interest.
He pointed to a 9.4% fall in property prices over the 12 months to October and said, "It's not the seller or the agent's fault if the price of real estate is dropping."
He also said the legislation "believed that the prices would always rise," which is a remarkable admission from the leader of the government that wrote it.
Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading Anoulack Chanthivong, who had championed the reforms for well over a year, said Parliament had passed the laws "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market."
He said the government wouldn't proceed with implementation while households were under financial pressure, and that Fair Trading would work with consumer groups and the industry to refine the changes.
Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James made a fair point when he said the laws should have been designed to withstand a downturn in the first place, noting that "property prices move in cycles."
The rejected offer rule was always the problem
I've long thought that underquoting is damaging.
It wastes buyers' time and money on building reports and finance applications; it leaves them emotionally drained after chasing homes that were never in their price range, and it erodes trust in our industry.
So I have no issue with the intent behind these laws. But the provision that would have stopped a vendor advertising below a previously rejected offer was a rule written by people who assumed the market only goes one way.
Picture a vendor who knocked back a $1.6 million offer in March because they believed the property was worth more.
Six months later, interest rates have moved, buyer sentiment has cooled and the market has softened.
Under the new rules, that vendor would have been locked into advertising at or above a number that no longer reflected reality, even if a job loss, divorce or death in the family meant they needed to sell.
That doesn't protect anyone, because buyers who could genuinely afford the property at today's value would never even see it in their search results.
REINSW chief executive Tim McKibbin had been making exactly this argument for months, warning that vendors are consumers too and the rules risked trapping them.
He welcomed the delay but was scathing about the way it happened, saying "Governments should be stable" and claiming the Minister had refused repeated requests to meet with the Institute.
He also noted something I think gets lost in this debate, which is that underquoting complaints tend to drop away in downturns, because agents are under pressure to quote realistically when buyers hold the upper hand.
A pause isn't open season
Some people will read the headlines and assume underquoting is now fair game in NSW, and that would be a mistake.
Underquoting has been illegal in NSW for years, and those existing laws haven't gone anywhere.
Agents must still have reasonable grounds for their estimated selling price, backed by comparable sales evidence, and they must revise that estimate when new evidence shows it's no longer reasonable.
That includes a genuine higher offer, so the core principle that you can't keep advertising below a real, rejected offer already exists in some form under the current law.
What's been paused are the additional, more prescriptive requirements and the much tougher penalties.
It's also worth remembering that a government announcement and the legally operative regulations aren't necessarily the same thing, so agents should be checking the current requirements directly with NSW Fair Trading rather than relying on media reports.
What this tells us about property policy
I've watched governments of all persuasions tinker with real estate rules for years and the pattern rarely changes.
Rules get designed in the middle of a boom, when buyers are frustrated and politicians want to be seen doing something, and then the market turns and the unintended consequences show up.
McKibbin made the point that successive governments have spent 26 years toughening underquoting penalties without solving the problem, and I think he's right that the answer lies in enforcement of sensible rules rather than ever more prescriptive ones.
Victoria offers a useful comparison.
Melbourne has had comparable-sales-based Statements of Information since 2017, and the state has now moved towards requiring auction reserves to be disclosed a week before auction day.
The NSW backflip should give policymakers in both states pause for thought, because laws that only work in a rising market are bad laws.
What it means for buyers, sellers and investors
If you're buying in NSW, nothing much changes in practice, because a price guide was never a valuation.
The investors and home buyers I work with don't anchor to an agent's quote; we research recent comparable sales and set their walk-away price before they ever inspect the property.
That discipline matters even more in a softer market, where some vendors are still clinging to last year's prices and others are being forced to meet the market.
If you're selling, the pause gives you and your agent more flexibility to adjust your price if the campaign isn't getting traction, which is a good thing in a cooler market.
But it's not a licence to set an unrealistically low guide to drum up interest, and a good agent won't suggest you do.
For long-term investors, the bigger lesson is the one Minns accidentally confirmed this week.
Property markets move in cycles, and anyone who builds a strategy, or a law, on the assumption that prices only go up is going to get caught out eventually.
Periods like this, when sentiment is soft, the headlines are messy and vendors are more motivated, are often when strategic investors find the best opportunities.
The key is to stay focused on investment-grade properties in locations with strong long-term demand, and not let policy noise distract you from a plan built for decades rather than months.
The bottom line
The NSW Government had a reasonable goal and a flawed piece of legislation, and to its credit it recognised the problem, even if it did so in about the most disruptive way possible.
Last-minute uncertainty helps nobody, and the industry, buyers and sellers all deserve clear, practical rules that hold up whether the market is rising or falling.
Hopefully the next 12 months are used to get that balance right.
If you're looking to buy a home, click here to find out about Metropole's home buying service. The seller has an agent representing them. Shouldn't you?
As buyers' agents we have no properties to sell. We work for one person - you.
The selling agent is legally working for the vendor, and knows at least five things about that property they don't want you to know. We put an experienced professional on your side of the table.
Click here now for an initial free clarity check.




