Table of contents
 - featured image
By Leanne Jopson

A rental cap would only worsen the rental crisis

The rental crisis in Australia has been an ongoing issue for some time now, with tenants struggling to find affordable and suitable accommodation.

As a result, there have been calls to cap rental increases as a solution to this problem and while this concept has been praised by some economists, I believe this show no understanding of how our housing markets operate.


Now I'm not downplaying the terrible rental crisis Australia is experiencing nor the financial hardship many tenants are experiencing with rents skyrocketing around Australia.

But industry insiders know that capping rental increases will only worsen the rental crisis in Australia.

Recently Ms Palaszczuk commented on a new report which showed the extent of the crisis showed the extent of the housing crisis.

According to the report, median rents rose 80% in the central Queensland city of Gladstone, 51% in Noosa and 33% on the Gold Coast over the past five years.

During that time, the proportion of private rentals considered affordable for low-income households halved from 26% to 13%.

"I understand that this is a big issue for families, they are constantly being faced with huge increases in rent," says Palaszczuk.

She further said:

"We're looking very seriously at how a rental cap can be put in place."

One of the main arguments in favour of capping rental increases is that it will provide tenants with greater stability and protection against rapidly increasing rents.

While this may be a short-term fix it will only worsen the situation in the long term.

This week Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk has announced a cap to rental price increases at one per year as opposed to every six-months to combat rental price pressures.
But talk of a more stringent cap on rental increases has not gone away with one prominent media outlet suggesting:
One state’s attempt to limit rent increases doesn’t go far enough to stop “price gouging” by landlords and real estate agents.
As I said these types of comments show a lack of understanding of how our housing markets operate

Here’s why…

  1. Fewer Investors

Capping rental increases will discourage property investors from entering the rental market.

Property investors rely on rental income to generate a return on their investment.

By capping rental increases, the potential return on investment is reduced, which makes investing in rental properties less attractive.

This, in turn, will result in fewer rental properties being available in the market, exacerbating the already existing rental crisis.

  1. Decreased property maintenance and upgrades.

Moreover, capping rental increases can discourage property investors from investing in property maintenance and upgrades.

Property investors need to make a return on their investment to justify the costs of maintaining and upgrading their properties.

If rental increases are capped, the potential return on investment is reduced, which may discourage property investors from investing in property maintenance and upgrades.

This can lead to a decline in the quality of rental properties, making it even harder for tenants to find suitable accommodation.

Market Crisis2

  1. Market distortions

Capping rental increases can create market distortions.

Rental markets are subject to supply and demand, and capping rental increases can disrupt this delicate balance.

It can create an artificial shortage of rental properties, which can lead to higher demand for existing properties and ultimately higher rents.

This is because property investors will try to maximise their rental income by setting rents at the highest level possible.

  1. Unintended consequences

Finally, capping rental increases can lead to unintended consequences.

Capping rental increases may lead to a reduction in the number of properties available for rent.

If landlords are unable to increase rents in line with market conditions, they may choose to sell their properties or use them for other purposes.

This would lead to a decrease in the overall supply of rental properties, further exacerbating the rental crisis.

Rental Crisis

Targeting “Greedy Property  Investors” is fuelling the rental crisis

Around one-third of dwellings in Australia are rental accommodations, and the vast majority of these are provided by mum and dad investors who only own one or two properties.

On the one hand, these investors are trying to secure their financial future and on the other, they're providing a service for people who choose not to buy a home or who cannot currently afford to buy a home.

Remember not all tenants a poor or are unable to buy a home-  many are tenants because of the stage of their life they are in.

For example, they've had a relationship separation, they are building a new home, they looking for a lifestyle change, they've had a job promotion or transfer or they are new migrants.

Governments see property investors as an ATM – a cheap way to raise more taxes and over the last decade governments and regulators have hammered property investors.

For example:

  • There have been a raft of market controls and interventions in favour of tenants
  • Investors are forced to pay higher interest rates than home buyers
  • Land tax increases have been punishing investors with a quasi “wealth tax.”
  • A 3% serviceability buffer is currently making it harder for investors to swap lenders

Rental Crisis Hope

The answer

While capping rental increases may seem like a solution to the rental crisis, it is not a viable one.

Capping rental increases is not the solution to the rental crisis in Australia.

Instead, we need to address the root causes of the crisis by increasing the supply of rental properties, streamlining planning and development processes, and encouraging investment in the rental market.

Making it easier for property investors to invest in and maintain their properties will create a more sustainable rental market that benefits both tenants and property investors.

About Leanne Jopson Leanne is National Director of Property Management at Metropole and a Property Professional in every sense of the word. With 20 years' experience in real estate, Leanne brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to maximise returns and minimise stress for their clients.
No comments


Copyright © 2024 Michael Yardney’s Property Investment Update Important Information
Content Marketing by GridConcepts