House or Apartment? Here is a better question…

People often ask me what makes a better investment, a house or an apartment.

I believe there is an even better question you should be asking to ensure you make the best decision.

The question is…

“Which has the better land value?”

Here are my thoughts…

Understand the Basics

Ask yourself, which part of the property will go up in value?

Money Profit Short Term Invest Value

The answer of course is the land, because the actual property itself will depreciate or lose value.

So it makes sense that whatever your budget, you need to ensure the bulk of the purchase price is made up of as much land as possible.

This may be much easier to work out with a house as opposed to an apartment, but it is still very much applicable.

For a house you can easily use a nearby comparable land sale, we often tend to use the rateable land value here in Queensland.

For houses up this way, we are generally looking for a minimum of around 70 – 80% Land to Asset ratio.

Therefore, 70 – 80% of the purchase price is made up of land.

Not only does this ensure superior growth, but it is also a good tool to recession proof your portfolio, as land is considerably less volatile.

The same applies for apartments in most cases.

We will take the total land or site value and divide it by the number of apartments in the complex.

Yes, it may be an apartment, but the land / site still has a value that will increase in the right locations.

It the majority of courses, it will fairly obviously be the house, but remember, not all land is equal.

Case Study

A client came to us many years ago with a budget of only $350,000; they wanted to buy a house as it had more land.

The proposal they were looking at was a new house and land package about 25-30km from Brisbane.

The Rateable land value was $75,000; this represented a Land to Asset Ratio of around 21.4%.

The other portion would have been represented by build costs, other commissions and fees that developers usually charge.

Land Tax

Alternately, we were able show them an apartment only 5km from Brisbane in a small boutique complex of only four.

The Rateable land value for the site here was $1million, so each apartment had an intrinsic land value of $250,000.

The Land to Asset ratio here is 73.5% and the land value has kept rising.

There is a clear difference in the land value of these two assets, even though the price is the same.

Case Study 2

Another client came to me many years ago and was assessing one of these brand new Inner City apartments in the Brisbane CBD.

It was nice, shiny and new with 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms with all the bells and whistles including pool, sauna and spa.

They were asking $650,000.

Applying the same formula, I looked at the site value and the amount of Apartments in the complex.

The Apartment In New Farm

Being central Brisbane the site was worth $10million, but there were 100 apartments in the complex.

That bought the Land value down to only $100,000 and a Land to Asset Ratio of only 15%.

In the end, we ended up buying them an old river front apartment with extensive views of the city.

It was older, with 2 bedrooms but only 1 bath and didn’t have all the bells and whistles

We ended up paying $656,000.

This was a much smaller site worth $5million, but there were only 10 other apartments in the complex.

With a Land value of $500,000, this bought the Land to Asset ratio up to 76.2% – a stark contrast!

I know what you are thinking, that is just the intrinsic value and it is not the actual land value.

Well 6 years later, a developer has just knocked on their door and offered all the owners $11million to buy them out.

Conclusion

Many people get confused when choosing between a house and an apartment.

Compare PropertyThe best piece of advice I would give is to get an understanding of what the Land to Asset Ratio is.

On most occasions, the house will come out on top.

However, remember, it is not the size of the land you should consider but the value.

Apartments in small boutique complexes offer great alternatives to houses located along way from things like employment hubs, public transport, schools and entertainment precincts.

Many smaller boutique complexes are on underutilised pieces of land ad that will get rarer and more scarce as times goes on.

It may represent an ideal opportunity for a developer who will be looking at the land and thinking what may be possible.

Otherwise, it will continue to be in higher demand and grow significantly faster in value to boost your wealth.

When doing your research in the future, dig a little deeper and remember the Land to Asset formula.

icon-podcast-large

Subscribe & don’t miss a single episode of Michael Yardney’s podcast

Hear Michael & a select panel of guest experts discuss property investment, success & money related topics. Subscribe now, whether you're on an Apple or Android handset.

Need help listening to Michael Yardney’s podcast from your phone or tablet?

We have created easy to follow instructions for you whether you're on iPhone / iPad or an Android device.

icon-email-large

Prefer to subscribe via email?

Join Michael Yardney's inner circle of daily subscribers and get into the head of Australia's best property investment advisor and a wide team of leading property researchers and commentators.


Brett Warren

About

Brett Warren is Director of Metropole Properties Brisbane and uses his 13 plus years property investment experience to advise clients how to grow, protect and pass on their build their wealth through property. Visit: www.brisbanebuyersagent.com.au


'House or Apartment? Here is a better question…' have 2 comments

    Avatar

    February 12, 2020 Sam

    Is there an easy way to check the estimated value of the land without going to an evaluator? Because many places are established and there is no recent sale history that involved land only

    Reply

      Michael Yardney

      February 13, 2020 Michael Yardney

      Council valuation show unimproved value for the land – but they are often out of date and therefore inaccurate. The alternative is looking at sales where the house is old and of ittle value – one that will be pulled down

      Reply


Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published.
CAPTCHA Image

*