4 times a property renovation won’t add value

You may have been misled.house depreciation calculator market property renovation plan build construction home

You see…a rash of popular reality TV programs have highlighted the easy money to be made in property renovating, which may have led you to believe that renovating is an easy and surefire strategy to generate profits from property.

But the reality is, renovating won’t always make you money.

In fact, sometimes a property upgrade can deplete your profits to the point where you would have been better off not even picking up a paintbrush in the first place.

These include:

1. Buying in a stagnant market

Or worse still, you buy when the local market is falling.

In this situation, renovations won’t necessarily increase the value of your property, but they may boost its rental appeal and potentially allow you to lift the asking rent.

The problem is compounded when investors buy a property to renovate and flip. 

This is hard enough to do profitably in a rising market and almost impossible to do in a stagnant market or if you bought in a “cheap” location where people aren’t prepared to, or can’t afford to, pay for more expensive properties.

2. When you over-capitalise

Browse the latest property listings on Domain or RealEstate.com.au and you’ll find countless examples of properties that have been over-capitalised.

For instance, an owner might add a pool in a suburb where pools aren’t highly sought-after, and therefore don’t add much value.  business man writing new house on beautiful green field use for multipurpose

Similarly installing high-end finishes to a low-end property is a move that rarely adds much of a premium to the property’s value or asking rent.

One example of an area that can be a huge money pit is landscaping.

I know an investor who obtained quotes to replace a crumbling retaining wall that lined the driveway of her property.

The quote was almost $17,000, but when she engaged a valuer for his professional opinion, he reported back:

“There’s no doubt that replacing the retaining wall will improve the function of your driveway, and it will look a lot neater as well,” the valuer said.

“But it won’t add much value to the property; I’d estimate around $5 -7,000.”

3. When you spend on renovations that don’t add visible value

Electrical work.


Wiring and internal infrastructure.

These are essential components of a fully functioning property – but when you spend money in these areas, buyers are generally none the wiser.

Of course, if repairs are required to get your property back into good working condition, you should go right and replace the faulty wiring or leaky pipes, but don’t expect them to add much value to your property or obtain a higher rental as potential purchasers or tenants would expect such services to be provided.

4. Structural renovations

These are the type of works that are sometimes necessary but can’t be seen so they won’t add much value to the property – things like plumbing works or re-stumping the property.

Sometimes larger structural renovations such as adding an extension could add significant value, but when you take into account the time delays including getting development approval through council, often your profits will disappear in holding costs.

That’s why, in general, I recommend beginning investors stick to cosmetic rather than structural renovations.

Having now warned you about some of the  potential issues, let me remind you that as our markets are likely to remain flat over the next few years adding value to your property through renovations is a great investment strategy.

Just make sure you own the right property (one that has significant owner occupier appeal) in the right location (where the demographic can afford to and are prepared to pay a premium to live) and that you undertake the appropriate renovations and don’t over capitalise.

Want more of this type of information?

Bryce Yardney


Bryce is a property development specialist, having successfully completed many development projects for Metropole's clients. Initially working as a Project Manager at Metropole since completing his Bachelor of Project Management in 2011, Bryce now acts as a buyers agent for clients, sourcing and evaluating properties with development potential.Visit Metropole.com.au

'4 times a property renovation won’t add value' have 2 comments

  1. July 10, 2016 @ 12:22 pm Greg

    How true. Have seen many unrenovated properties fetch unbelievable amounts of money that would certainly confirm that the cost and problems associated with renovations is not worthwhile. There is also the fact that people want to renovate to their own taste and requirements. Others feel that they may be paying too much for a renovated property. So many people do not value a renovation in the same way that the renovator does.


    • July 10, 2016 @ 1:00 pm Michael Yardney

      You’re right Greg. Some people seem to pay extra for the ability to have fun doing a renovation


Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published.



Michael's Daily Insights

Join Michael Yardney's inner circle of daily subscribers.

NOTE: this daily service is a different subscription to our weekly newsletter so...