Is the Federal Government’s attempting to make housing more affordable just tinkering around the edges?
Is there something that can be done or is it just a reality that some people will never be able to afford to buy a property?
HERE’S A TRANSCRIPT OF THE INTERVIEW
(Alternatively you can listen to the short podcast at the top)
Kevin: There’s a lot of talk about how we can make housing more affordable in Australia.
But is it going to be possible? And what will be the likely impacts of that?
What’s your view on this Michael?
Michael: Firstly let me explain my position.
In my blended family I have six children, nine grandchildren and one on the way.
So I’m acutely aware of the challenges that young people have, and I have a number of generations below me that I want to be able to live in good housing, in a fantastic country, in big capital cities.
But having said that, I think we have to change our expectations, because if you lived in London, Paris or New York you wouldn’t really expect your children to be able to buy a house as their first homE, and you wouldn’t even really expect them to buy an apartment first off either.
Kevin: So has it become unaffordable for first-home buyers?
Michael: If you talk about our big capital cities of Melbourne and Sydney – which are international cities, coming up to five million people in them, situated on a harbour, commerce hubs and employment hubs – it is getting more and more unaffordable, and it’s likely that there will be generations of people who will never be able to own a home and who will always be renters.
Many of the things that the government are doing is really just tinkering around the edges, but in general, every time the government or Treasury gets involved, it seems to have the wrong effect; it pushes house prices up.
Kevin: What about the first-home owner’s grant?
Michael: In the beginning of July this year, Victoria has new first-home owner’s grants and is getting rid of stamp duty.
And this means that currently, first-home owners are not buying – they’re biding their time.
They’re holding off because all of a sudden, they’re going to be given an extra $10,000.
And similarly, I know a number of sellers who have decided, “I’m not going to sell, because I know property values are going to shoot up in July.”
The problem is we have to look at the past, and politicians have forgotten to do that.
In 2010–2011 when the first-home owner grants were given in New South Wales and when stamp duty was abolished, what happened was that this gave first-home owners an extra $10,000, $15,000, $20,000.
What they were able to do was use these funds for leverage when they went to the banks, because they had more deposit because they didn’t have to put it aside for stamp duty, and they had another $70,000 or $80,000, which they paid for houses.
And in general, first-home owners want to live where the action is, so they buy established properties.
Somebody has to sell those properties and those owners upgraded.
The first-home owner grant became a second homeowner or established homeowner boost, and what it did was give a fantastic boost to the established property market in the inner and middle ring suburbs, and I predict the same is going to happen in Victoria this year.
It’s not going to make properties more affordable; it’s going to keep this good, strong property market in Melbourne even stronger.
Kevin: Just a comment on negative gearing for a moment.
It’s probably one of the most unpopular taxes, but we really do rely heavily on private investors, and without it, you’d have to say that private investors probably wouldn’t be as attracted to the market and therefore rent would likely go up.
And that’s certainly not going to achieve the outcome anyone wants.
Michael: The outcome people are wanting is more affordable housing, but when 70% of Australians own their own home or are paying it off, the only way to make your and my house affordable to other people is to decrease the value of our house, and nobody wants that.
So how do you make housing more affordable without decreasing the value of that $6.9 trillion worth of residential real estate in Australia?
One way people say is get rid of the ugly, greedy property investors who are pushing up the prices because of negative gearing.
That’s fiddling at the edges, and as you say, we still have to provide rental accommodation for a third of our population.
The other thing is they say, “Let’s get more supply. Let’s go to regional Australia. Let’s have fast trains. Let’s have more employment out in the regional areas.”
But that’s not where first-home owners want to live.
In general, they want to live close to all the amenities, close to all the action, and close to where their friends are.
And we’re not building enough of the right sort of properties for them.
Kevin: So what do you think is the answer?
Michael: It’s a cliché, but this is a First-World problem.
It’s one of the prices you pay for living in the best cities in the world.
Melbourne for six years in a row has been voted the most livable city in the world.
Sydney and Perth and Brisbane have been high up on those lists as well.
It’s one of the costs that comes with the pleasure and enjoyment and comfort and safety of living in Australia.
Kevin: Your advice to young people?
Michael: Save, consider rent-vesting, consider borrowing from the bank of mom and dad.
Don’t give up.
Maybe you should just lower your expectations of what your first home could look like.
Kevin: Lower those expectations and do whatever you have to do to get into the market.
Michael: You have to get in the market because if you don’t, it’s going to run away from you
Kevin: Thank you so much for your time Michael,
Michael: My pleasure.
Subscribe & don’t miss a single episode of michael yardney’s podcast
Hear Michael & a select panel of guest experts discuss property investment, success & money related topics. Subscribe now, whether you're on an Apple or Android handset.
Need help listening to michael yardney’s podcast from your phone or tablet?
We have created easy to follow instructions for you whether you're on iPhone / iPad or an Android device.
Prefer to subscribe via email?
Join Michael Yardney's inner circle of daily subscribers and get into the head of Australia's best property investment advisor and a wide team of leading property researchers and commentators.