Stuck in traffic: busting Melbourne versus Sydney myths and identifying the worst commutes

For Melbourne drivers who comfort themselves with the thought that traffic congestion is worse in Sydney, sorry but new analysis shows overall delays are similar, but some commutes are especially bad, writes…

Marion Terrill, Grattan Institutecars, traffic, population

Crawling along in low gear, Melbourne drivers often comfort themselves with the thought that at least they’re not in Sydney, where “everyone knows” traffic delays are longer and even more frustrating. Sorry, Melburnians, but you’re kidding yourselves.

New analysis for a forthcoming report by the Grattan Institute debunks several myths about traffic congestion in Australia’s biggest cities – including the conventional wisdom that Sydney-siders are doing it tougher.

Sydney may have 340,000 more people and an enormous harbour constricting movements from one part of the city to another, but Melbourne is pretty much on a par when it comes to congestion.

Twin pictures of congestion

Chart 1 shows the delay that an average CBD commuter endures in Sydney and Melbourne, compared to how long it would take to do the trip in the early hours of the morning when the only constraints are traffic lights and speed limits.

file   mganj
Data for more than 300 routes travelling to and from the CBD were collected 25 times each day over about 12 weeks between March and June 2017.
Grattan analysis of Google Maps data, Author provided

In the morning peak, an average Melbourne CBD commuting trip takes close to 70% longer than it would in the middle of the night.

The 11-kilometre trip from Brighton takes an extra 13 minutes, and the 30km trip from Caroline Springs an extra 20 minutes.

The 9km from Coburg take an extra 14 minutes, while the 17km from Doncaster take an extra 20 minutes.

It’s similar in Sydney.

The average morning commute to the CBD takes 50-60% longer than it would in the middle of the night. 

The 40km trip from Liverpool takes an extra 32 minutes, while a trip of similar length from Blacktown typically takes an extra 20.

Driving the 17km from Manly takes an extra 21 minutes, while the 7km trip from the airport takes an extra 12.

It doesn’t take quite as long to get home from the city. In the afternoon peak, an average trip takes up to 60% longer than it would in the middle of the night.

But it’s harder to avoid the delay: peak “hour” is much longer in the evening than in the morning.

Any time from 3.30pm to 6pm you can expect your trip to take at least 40% longer.

We found these patterns by analysing Google Maps estimates of travel times for more than 300 routes across Sydney and Melbourne.

The data include 25 travel-time estimates every day for several months.

This includes commutes to the CBD and other employment centres, important freight routes, shorter trips within the inner, middle and outer rings, and cross-city trips.

So which drivers have the worst run?

Here’s a finding that might surprise drivers who have to crawl over the West Gate Bridge to get to and from work: the worst place to commute to Melbourne’s CBD is not from the rapidly growing western suburbs, but from the northeastern suburbs.  intersection-2262239_1920

That probably won’t surprise you if your commute includes the Eastern Freeway.

Chart 2 shows the typical delay for commuters coming to Melbourne’s CBD from the southeast, northeast, north, south and west.

The northeast is the stand-out worst performer, as those who live in Doncaster, Heidelberg and beyond know all too well.

Interestingly, people commuting from the west face much more modest delays.

file   pyyq
Grattan analysis of Google Maps data, Author provided

Sydney does not have a single region where residents can so clearly expect bad city commutes.

That doesn’t mean there’s no congestion. And neither does it mean that it’s just people going to the CBD who are caught up in the commuting tangle.

It’s also all the freight vehicles, tradespeople, students going to school or uni, people going to appointments in business hours, and others going elsewhere but still caught up in the snarl of traffic.

Chart 3 shows a selection of trips that don’t include the Sydney CBD but do have delays, with the size of delay depending on the direction of the trip.

file   rbzya
In Sydney, the delay depends more on the direction of the trip, than what side of the city commuters are driving from.
Grattan analysis of Google Maps data, Author provided

The how-long-does-it-take-you-to-get-to-work story involves more than roads. sydney job car traffic

One-quarter of Sydney commuters and 18% of Melbourne commuters use public transport, and these figures are much higher for commuters to the CBD.

Nonetheless, around eight of every ten kilometres of travel by Sydney and Melbourne residents is by car.

The ConversationWhat happens on our roads affects the daily lives of most city dwellers, as well as the social and economic rhythms of the city.

The Grattan Institute will publish a fuller analysis of congestion in coming months, to help governments make the best use of our transport networks – and reduce your time on the road.

Marion Terrill, Transport Program Director, Grattan Institute

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.


Subscribe & don’t miss a single episode of Michael Yardney’s podcast

Hear Michael & a select panel of guest experts discuss property investment, success & money related topics. Subscribe now, whether you're on an Apple or Android handset.

Need help listening to Michael Yardney’s podcast from your phone or tablet?

We have created easy to follow instructions for you whether you're on iPhone / iPad or an Android device.


Prefer to subscribe via email?

Join Michael Yardney's inner circle of daily subscribers and get into the head of Australia's best property investment advisor and a wide team of leading property researchers and commentators.

Guest Expert


Apart from our regular team of experts, we frequently publish commentary from guest contributors who are authorities in their field.

'Stuck in traffic: busting Melbourne versus Sydney myths and identifying the worst commutes' have no comments

Be the first to comment this post!

Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published.